I say emphatically YES.
There have now been 20 seasons of Survivor. I admit...I have watched only 3. However, a few weeks ago, I got suckered into the Villains vs. the Heroes. Not sure how or why but for some reason, on a Thursday night, my TV found its way to channel two. There I met up with a guy named Russell who apparently was a Villain. Not sure how one becomes a villain or a hero? Do the Villains lie and cheat more than the Heroes? Do the Villains actually try to win the game while the Heroes just try to keep their honor? I'm not sure nor do I care to do any research to find out. All I know is that I was a "hero" for not having indulged myself in this terrible show but now consider myself a "villain" because I gave in to temptation that fateful Thursday night.
So why is this the worst show on TV? (hyperbole....maybe....because I recently watched about 10 minutes of The Hills...and I almost slit my wrists about 5 different times).
The reason I consider Survivor the worst show is because the best players NEVER win. Only the losers win. How can a show reward one million dollars to the worst player. No other reality show does this. It's always "the best singer" or "the best cook" or "the best duhsigner."
I might be wrong but in all 3 Survivor shows that I actually watched...the real winner went home a loser. Why? Because they allow the bitter contestants who got outwitted, outplayed, and outlasted to vote for a winner. These guys are pissed. Have you ever played Mafia before? Everytime you lose....you are upset and angry at the person who you feel is responsible. Sometimes you form an alliance with the person sitting next to you only to find out they are Mafia....this makes you mad and angry and you absolutely DO NOT want that person to win because you feel outsmarted by that person. It is a blow to one's ego.
In Survivor they let the losers vote for a winner. This goes against everything we have ever been taught in the TV era that is reality. Naturally, the guy who controls the game...loses. Instead the girl who rides his coat-tails and never makes enemies wins. That person never "outwitted nor outplayed" anyone. She only "outlasted."
Same thing happened last night when I watched the finale. Russell was the best player. He controlled the game and did what Survivor's motto teaches....outwit, outplay, outlast. Never has the motto said, "BeFriend, BeNice, BeHonest."
But did Russell win? Of course not. The "jury" has to blame someone for their ineptitude and they all blamed Russell. They all say the same thing, "You're a meanie Russell. You're a liar Russell. You're a schemer Russell." So...out of 9 votes...Russell gets ZERO.
Instead the winner goes to: Some chick who I never saw in the four episodes I watched. Don't even remember her name. I didn't even know she was in the show. When they had the final three talk...I said to myself, "Who's that chick? No way she wins. She never won a challenge nor outwitted nor outplayed anyone."
Apparently she is now a 2 time winner. Which is why I believe Survivor to be....THE WORST SHOW ON TV.
(well...besides The Hills).



I have to disagree, I'm a Survivor lover and loyalist. Boston Rob said it best when he said that Russell doesn't play to win he plays to get to the end. Only having watched 3 seasons and 4 episodes of each season, no offense, but I'm not sure that you are an expert in the subject of Survivor. I would like to hear Eric's take on it since he has faithfully watched all 20 seasons. I've seen real winners win the million by winning challenges, immunity, friends, lying some, but along the way not making enemies. Everyone hates Russell because he is a scheming troll. It made me happy that for the 2nd season in a row he got 0 votes. If he were smart he would have learned the 1st time that his gameplay was not that of a winner. That being said, he makes the show really enjoyable, but so did Johnny Fairplay. Love the post, sorry for the lecture :)
ReplyDeleteTHANK YOU JEN! for saving me the lecture! As Jeff Probst said in the reunion show, the Jury vote is a major element of the show...if you don't like it go be on another show. That's what makes Survivor so genius. Everyone can lie, cheat, and steal their way to the end--but only a true winner can then sway a jury of 9 people who had to put up with them to give them a million dollars. I, myself, don't love the coat tail strategy and thought Parvarti should have won. Sorry Dro, you are WAY off on this one.
ReplyDeleteP.S. I am going with The Bachelor as the worst show on TV.
ReplyDeleteDro. You're mental. You have no credibility because you think The Bachelor is the best show on TV. Did the best chick win in that show? No, Mr. Ed won. Survivor rules...and so does Russel. I don't know why Jen and Steph are such Russel haters. That guy is classic and hilarious and I'm glad he won the $100K from the audience vote - but they're right, you've got to play the game and implement the right strategy. Sandra is an ugly Mexican. Parvati is hot, so I would like her to win also. PS. Can you change the format on this blog so it's not size 36 font in a skinny column down the middle.
ReplyDeleteFirst, I would like to agree on the format change for the blog - its horrible.
ReplyDeleteSecond, I would like to say that this was my first season of Survivor (we started watching in California and finished by watchin over the internet). I think the show rocks! It is an absolutly fascinating social psych leason. Much of the tags of the show - including its name are - correct. You win by just surviving and being the least threatening. If I were to watch it again I would probably skip the final episode - it was by far the most boring (by far). But watching the other episodes and seeing people make stupid decision after stupid decision (including volitle Russel) was awsome (I loved it when J.T. gives Russell the idol - that is not scriptable its soooo stupid). I like Survivor.